Women of the Bible - Deborah

Historical Background
Life in Israel was difficult during the age of the judges (~1400-1050 B.C.). Joshua had put down all major organized resistance in the land and divided Canaan amongst the 12 tribes. There were, however, still pockets of resistance and Yahweh wanted these pagans driven out of the land. Judges 1.19 sums up the situation very well:

The LORD was with the men of Judah. They took possession of the hill country, but they were unable to drive the people from the plains, because they had iron chariots.

Archeology confirms that the Israelites lived in the hill country. Furthermore, the Israelites did not know how to work iron, but their adversaries (the Philistines) did. This gave these canaanites a military and economic advantage, thus they ruled the fertile plans near the Mediterranean Sea while the Israelites were confined to the hills.

Ehud, a prior Judge, died and Israel fell back into Sin (Judges 4.1). This is the normal cycle for Judges: sin, servitude, supplication, salvation. Deborah continues this pattern as the people cry out to Yahweh (4.3) and he sends them a new Judge: Deborah (4.4). Deborah is unique among judges in that she was also a prophet, and like other prophets, she spoke the word or Yahweh (3.28, 4.6).

What is a Judge?
A judge was a supreme ruler, in the name of Yahweh, during this period. He or she was the spiritual, political and military leader of one or more tribes of Israel, who was raised up by Yahweh (2.16) to save His people. Deborah should be viewed, as should the other judges, as part of this larger context.

Judges tells the story of Deborah twice: in chapter 4 in prose and in chapter 5 in poetry. Chapter 5 was written by Deborah (even though the introduction says “Deborah and Barak”, all the pronouns are feminine-singular). Most scholars think Deborah’s Song (Judges 5) is the oldest writing in the Bible (O. Eissfeldt, The Old Testament: An Introduction, 1965: 100-101). I find it fascinating that a woman wrote the oldest scripture we have.

We must avoid projecting feminist or anti-feminist ideas into this story. Remember, this is primarily a story about Yahweh raising up a leader to save His people. One mistake that is made by feminists is to diminish Deborah’s introduction as the “wife of Lepidoth.” Instead, they try to translate this phrase as, “a woman of valor.” We must set this story in its proper historical and societal context. This was a strongly patriarchal society, people were known by what family they belonged to and families were named by the patriarch of the family. Introducing Deborah as the wife of Lepidoth is a very standard introduction for this period. Furthermore, it does not diminish Deborah, but rather shows that a wife can be a leader raised up by Yahweh, even in this strongly patriarchal society.

On the other hand, anti-feminists have attacked Deborah on various fronts. Consider David L. Brown's explanation of Deborah:

Yahweh's perfect will is for men to lead, but when men will not assume their responsibilities, Yahweh uses women. The men in Deborah's day were weak and chicken-hearted. Barak, the captain of the armies of Israel, proves this to be true. He refused to go into battle unless Deborah went with him. Deborah had to remind him that Yahweh had said it is time to fight. Deborah had to encourage and challenge him to go. Deborah had to go with him!
"And Barak said unto her, If thou wilt go with me, then I will go: but if thou wilt not go with me, then I will not go" Judges 4:8
Deborah clearly realized that this was neither right nor natural for her to have the leadership position.

Always beware an author who calls something “clear” when it is not. First, Brown says that the men here were “weak and chicken-hearted.” We do not see either of these points made in Judges 4 or 5. At Deborah’s command, 10,000 men assembled to attack the Canaanites, who had better weapons and who had oppressed the Israelites for twenty years. What is “chicken-hearted” about that? It is not explained why Barak refuses to go without Deborah. Brown (and others in his camp) assumes it is because Barak is a poor leader. Barak is the one who assembles the 10,000 men at Deborah’s command. He leads them into battle and destroys the entire Canaanite army. Barak seems to have a reasonable grasp of leadership. Perhaps it is the huge respect that Deborah had during this time that causes Barak to demand her accompaniment. As Yahweh’s judge and prophet, Barak may have viewed her as a talisman (i.e. the Arc of the Covenant) to be carried before the army to ensure victory. This is just another possible explanation. As I said above, we just are not told why Barak demands this of Deborah.

Second, Brown says that it “was neither right nor natural for [Deborah] to have a leadership position.” Where does this idea come from? Not Judges 4-5. Yahweh raised up judges to save His people (Judges 2.16). Yahweh choose Deborah and I do not believe he made a mistake nor that He would have chosen a male if one of good quality would have been available. Yahweh has no problem using poor-quality men to accomplish His plans (i.e. Jonah).

Some have also attacked Deborah’s prophet status, but she is a prophet by any definition of the word. She speaks for Yahweh (4.6), prophesies the outcome of the battle (4.7, 9) and encourages faithfulness and obedience (4.14). These are normal activities of prophets and Deborah’s gender limits her in no way as a prophet of Yahweh.

Back to the Main Story
At this point, it is worth pulling our thoughts back to the main point of Judges 4-5: Yahweh saves His people. Consider Judges 5.4:

O LORD, when you went out from Seir,
when you marched from the land of Edom,
the earth shook, the heavens poured,
the clouds poured down water.

To reach the battlefield, Sisera’s army had to dismantle their chariots and reassemble them on the flat plain. The rain and mud would have made this difficult and made the chariots bog down in the mud. Yahweh apparently neutralized the technological advantage of the Canaanites and led his people to victory against them. Deborah’s Song is not primarily about Deborah, Barak, or Jael (who killed Sisera by driving a tent peg through his head); it is about Yahweh saving His people.

Summary
God raised up a judge, prophet and military leader named Deborah. She led several tribes of Israel (including all the men of those tribes) as Yahweh commanded her. Barak recognized her authority, obeyed her instructions, and so won the battle at Megiddo. Yahweh was pleased with this and granted victory over the Canaanites. Forty years of peace followed because they obeyed Yahweh’s will.

Charme E. Robarts (Deborah, Essays on Women in Earliest Christianity, Volume II) profoundly states:

To suggest that Deborah would not have played the role of military or spiritual leader if the men of Israel had been responsible is to make current gender conflicts apply to the ancient setting rather than allowing the text to apply its meaning to the present situation.

For a visual (and somewhat accurate) representation of this story, refer to The Brick Testament.