Genesis 1.1-2.3, the creation of everything...a summary
Genesis 2.4-2.25, the creation of humans...a detailed account
Genesis 3.1-3.24, the fall
Now the first accounting of creation summarizes the creation of humans into one verse (Genesis 1.27):
27 So God created human beings in his own image.
In the image of God he created them;
male and female he created them.
While the second accounting gives much detail about the creation of people, this first account boils it down to the two most important aspects of the creation of people.
1. Humans are created in the image of God.
2. Humans were created with two types: male and female.
It is so important that we get these two points that each one is written twice!
In this accounting there is no difference between male and female humans. Both were created by God and both were created in God's image. Both were commanded to rule over the earth and to populate it. They are not in opposition nor indistinguishable, but rather they live in community with one another in common commission and function.
The second accounting of creation focuses on the creation of the humans, leaving out most of the rest of the creation. First, God creates a beautiful garden then He places the man in the garden to watch over it. He gives the man one rule: don't eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. God sees that the man needs a companion and parades the animals in front of the man so that he sees this need as well. Then God creates the woman from the man's rib and the man cries out in excitement at his new companion!
Some claim this second creation story demonstrates men's authority over women. There are four main points to this argument:
1. Man was created first and therefore has dominion over women.
2. Man named woman, demonstrating his authority over her.
3. Woman was created from man's rib, demonstrating her dependence on him.
4. Woman was created to be a helper to Man, indicating his authority over her.
The flaws in these arguments are simple:
1. There is no inherent dominion on the grounds of creation order. The animals don't rule over the people and the fish and birds don't rule over the land animals, yet that was the order they were created in.
2. God commanded the man to name all the animals but God does not give the man the authority to name the woman. On the contrary, the man names the woman (and also himself) out of spontaneous joy at the sight of her!
3. If we apply this rule to man, then he is dependent on and ruled by the dirt he was created from...which makes no sense at all.
4. This is a complete misrepresentation of the word “helper.” This exact Hebrew word is used several times in the Hebrew Bible to refer to God, i.e. God is our helper. If this word “helper” indicates dominance or authority then God would have to be under the authority of those people He was a helper to. Of course, this is asinine.
The fact is the second creation story is really about the woman. She is the climax and the pinnacle of the creation. She gets five verses describing the need for her and then the creation of her. Notice the man gets zero verses! He is just placed in the garden. If there is any indication of superiority in this chapter it is that the woman (who is the only creature who is created from another creature) is the crown-jewel of God's creation.
The fact is, from both creation stories we see a perfect world, just as God created it and intended it. In this world there is no distinction in terms of role or authority between the man and the woman.
7 comments:
Great post and good discussion Keith. I think this detail will be helpful in the 'helper' discussion from chapter 2.
The Hebrew word for helper transliterated is 'ezer, as in Moses’ son Eliezer (meaning God Helps us). It occurs 21 times in the OT, 2 describe Eve, 3 are in the prophets in a negative connotation describing Israel (Isa 30:5, Eze 12:14, Dan 11:34) and the other 16 describe God, mostly as Praise in Psalms.
What the meaning of this word indicates to me is a situation where there is a more powerful being that loves enough to provide assistance when someone they love needs it. Kind of like when I am trying to find the jar of Jalapenos and my stupid male brain can only see and recognize one object at a time. I have a loving wife who is blessed with the ability to decipher the entire refrigerator in 1.5 seconds and find them immediately.
Tim
LOL ok I had to leave one more - quoting from your orignal post,
"she is the climax and the pentacle of creation"
Isn't a pentacle one of those upside down triangle Satan symbols? hahahahaha I think you meant 'pinnacle' but in a study on women...
Tim
Thanks for the spelling correction Tim. I've fixed the posting...is that allowed in blogging? Or are you supposed to just live with your mistakes. I say blogging should be a world of forgiveness...
-Keith
Dude, fix away. I probably edit my posts, like, 15 times IMMEDIATELY after posting cause I find so many mistakes. Sometimes, it (seriously) takes me 30 minutes to "finish" a 5 line post.
How do you like my pitcha' on here?
Oh, yeah, about the actual post......hmmm.....let me read it first.
I have found additional information concerning point #2 that man named woman, demonstrating his authority over her. In Genesis 16.14 Hagar names God. If naming someone demonstrates authority over that one, then Hagar has authority over God. That makes no sense, of course.
-Keith
Post a Comment